So, today I got sad again. I was digging through the shelves to find books for a friend of a friend who is converting. I came to a book on Jewish prayer, and immediately felt both drawn to it and viscerally averse to it, scared of it, unwilling to engage with it.
I removed it from one inaccessible shelf, and put it on one of “my” shelves, saying I would read it later. But I was still scared, so I just faced it and sat right down and read a chapter on my favorite prayer in the service. Readers, I am very proud of myself. I can hardly remember what I read, but I am very proud that I decided to open up and face the thing and cry while I was doing it.
Why did I cry? I cried because I feel like having only one child excludes me from important parts of communal Judaism. My feeling is a fact, but it doesn’t correspond with actual facts. I am not excluded from anything. Still, I feel like less of a Jew, like I’m not doing my share. Saturdays, Sabbaths, are still the days when the demons of infertility are most present, and not coincidentally, it’s the one day in which I am not frantically busy and in constant motion. Today we didn’t even go to synagogue, so I didn’t have that useful distraction — people who know organized religion know it can be a distraction from the divine and ultimate as much as it can be a conduit for it.
I talked to Daniel about it, with some trepidation, because he believes the statute of limitations for sadness is up, has been up for about 364 days. He also believes, although he doesn’t say, that I am spiritually lazy because I don’t engage with Judaism intellectually. I go to synagogue, but not to The Books. I follow some obscure customs, but I don’t learn (in Jewish culture, learning is a non-transitive verb. The what is assumed: Talmud, Torah, Commentary. “What’s Jacob doing?” “He’s learning.” “Oh, who’s he learning with?” “With David and Jonathan and Adina.”) He is ferociously against the Judaism that’s all about the children. So he was not sympathetic, but he made an effort.
Me, I was heroic, if I do say so myself. I told him I was sad, and that it may be irrational, but that it’s also the starting point, not the ending point. My reaction against the books, my feeling of being unsafe and unsettled is something I need to get into and think about and talk about. I was, dear readers, quite brave to have this conversation. Daniel gets very thunderous sometimes about Judaism and right behavior, and prickly about my sadness in any case, but especially This Sadness. Things have been going very well for us this past week, and I was clearly upsetting the applecart.
I am scared of prayer. I prayed so intently for so long, even before we officially tried to conceive another child. I prayed for Daniel’s heart to change. I prayed for relief during some really rough times we had. I prayed, probably incorrectly, but with great intensity. I am scared to be intense again. I am scared to beseech again and be told “no” again (although I have had some very nice, small but essential “yes”s of late). I am scared of being so vulnerable before God, I really am. I have been vulnerable before and was left to sort it out with earthly, rather than heavenly, resources. (Some would say there was a heavenly hand behind the marshalling of those earthly resources. Sister, that makes you and my other beloved commenters officially a chorus of angels.) I don’t want to pray intensely and seriously and be reminded of how very little I understand about God, faith, providence, intervention, and theodicy. I am at a permanent disadvantage with God, and I don’t like it. I want to know the terms of the exchange, and know they are in my favor.
I want God to make the first move, dammit. A wise teacher might say, “How is He going to talk to you, if you aren’t talking to Him?” And petulant me would say, “That’s His problem. He has a way of making Himself known as He chooses.” I want Him to tell me 1) why my other child never came to be; 2) for what good; 3) how He’s going to make it come out beautifully in the end. I can only stay out of compulsive comparisons, of the pursuit of “as if” for so long. Each time is longer, but I find myself back here eventually.
Another thing about Jewish books and Jewish teachers: they’re all so very certain. With the exception of the sweet-but-not-very-intellectual Rabbi Kushner (yes, the guy who wrote, “When Bad Things Happen to Good People”) they aren’t really into the whole feeling business. I need a book for the struggling, not the people who want to get it right, or be confirmed in their certainty. When I ask Daniel about this, he gives me a lecture on the perils of customization, on how I always reject things if they aren’t precisely what I’m looking for, how I don’t give things a chance. Is that helpful? Who thinks that’s helpful? (Daniel and I are good in a crisis, unless the crisis is happening to our spouse.)
No good ending, just the realization that this is another realm. This is the project, perhaps, for the second year.